MPs sign up for grievance of Labour's anti-Semitism code

MPs join criticism of Labour's anti-Semitism code

Image copyright Getty Images

Campaigners and some Labour MPs have criticised the party's new code of conduct on anti-Semitism.

The code states that "anti-Semitism is racism. It is unacceptable in our party and in wider society".

But some critics think it does not sign up in full to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's working definition of anti-Semitism.

Labour insists it does meet the full IHRA definition, which it says was adopted by the party in December 2016.

Labour MPs Chuka Umunna, Liz Kendall and Anna Turley are among those who have been critical.

Mr Umunna tweeted he was "utterly appalled":

Skip Twitter post by @ChukaUmunna

Our values dictate that we treat all groups the same and yet, again and again, we see examples of the Jewish community being treated differently to other groups by the Labour Party. This is discrimination, pure and simple, and it is totally unacceptable.

— Chuka Umunna (@ChukaUmunna) July 5, 2018

Report

End of Twitter post by @ChukaUmunna

While Ms Turley tweeted:

Skip Twitter post by @annaturley

I am sincerely sorry to Jewish people in this country. Labour are getting this all terribly wrong. Not in my name. https://t.co/wQZUVSd4na

— Anna Turley MP (@annaturley) July 5, 2018

Report

End of Twitter post by @annaturley

The Jewish Leadership Council and the Board of Deputies of British Jews said in a joint statement that it was "impossible to understand" why Labour had not adopted the IHRA definition in full - as the UK Jewish community, governments and local councils had done.

Labour's code, which was approved by a sub-committee of its National Executive Committee, came about after the 2016 Chakrabarti inquiry into anti-Semitism.

It does endorse the IHRA's working definition of anti-Semitism and includes behaviours it lists as likely to be regarded as anti-Semitic - but critics think it leaves out four examples:

• Accusing Jewish people of being more loyal to Israel than their home country
• Claiming that Israel's existence as a state is a racist endeavour
• Requiring higher standards of behaviour from Israel than other nations
• Comparing contemporary Israeli policies to those of the Nazis

However, Labour insisted the examples which are not in the bulleted section are addressed in the guidelines.

• How the Labour anti-Semitism saga unfolded

• Corbyn apologises for 'hurt' caused by anti-Semitism in Labour

In their joint statement, Jonathan Goldstein of the Jewish Leadership Council and Marie van der Zyl of the Board of Deputies said it was "for Jews to determine themselves what anti-Semitism is".

The Labour Against Anti-Semitism campaign described it as a "toothless document" adding: "The Labour Party already has very little credibility left as the anti-racist body it has always claimed to be.

"The formal adoption of this document would see any remaining credibility lost, perhaps permanently."

A Labour source said Labour Against Anti-Semitism's claims were "ludicrous and entirely false".

And a spokesman for the Labour Party said: "These are the most detailed and comprehensive guidelines on anti-Semitism adopted by any political party in this country.

"They draw on the IHRA examples and other sources to provide practical examples of anti-Semitism which can be applied to complaints cases and used in political education programmes to foster deeper understanding of anti-Semitism among members."

Mr Umunna and Ms Turley are not the only Labour MPs to criticise the code. Bassetlaw MP John Mann tweeted:

Skip Twitter post by @JohnMannMP

The Macpherson definition of racism has been accepted until now by every mainstream political party in Parliament. The Labour NEC are the first to refuse to accept it, which has huge consequences. https://t.co/U3IZVcCXOk

— John Mann (@JohnMannMP) July 5, 2018

Report

End of Twitter post by @JohnMannMP

While Leicester West MP Liz Kendall said on Twitter:

Skip Twitter post by @leicesterliz

IHRA definition of anti semitism is used by U.K, Scottish & Welsh Govts, 124 local councils & Crown Prosecution Service. In @UKLabour we should be holding ourselves to the same high standards. https://t.co/9RLOt66C9m

— Liz Kendall (@leicesterliz) July 5, 2018

Report

End of Twitter post by @leicesterliz

The 2016 Chakrabarti report found Labour was not overrun by anti-Semitism but noted an "occasionally toxic atmosphere".

Leader Jeremy Corbyn said in March that he recognised that anti-Semitism had "surfaced" in the party and said he was "sincerely sorry for the pain which has been caused" and pledged to "redouble my efforts" to tackle it, after Jewish groups accused him of not doing enough.

Original Article

Politics

January 27, 2019